Skip to main content
ClienteleCLNTL
Home/Game Subscriptions/PlayStation Plus Extra vs Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

PlayStation Plus Extra vs Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Head-to-head across 5 dimensions — speed, privacy, value, and more. Scores are independent and not influenced by affiliate relationships.

Reviewed by the Clientele Research Team · Last checked 9 days ago (2026-07-15)
PlayStation Plus Extra
$16.99/mo — 400+ PS4/PS5 games
6.7/10
vs
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
$22.99/mo — Xbox + PC + cloud + EA Play
9.0/10WINNER
SCORE BREAKDOWN
DIMENSION
PlayStation Plus Extra
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate
EDGE
Library
Total number of available games and quality and diversity of the catal…
8.5
9.5
Xbox ↑
Value
Price per month relative to what you get — library depth, day-one acce…
7.5
8.0
Xbox ↑
Day-One
Whether major new first-party games are included in the subscription o…
4.0
8.5
Xbox ↑
Platforms
How many devices and platforms the subscription works on — console, PC…
7.0
9.5
Xbox ↑
Extras
Additional benefits beyond game access — cloud gaming, online multipla…
6.5
9.5
Xbox ↑
Overall Score
6.7
9.0
Xbox wins
OUR VERDICT
PlayStation Plus Extra

Best for: PlayStation owners who want a large on-demand library without paying for features they won't use. Extra's 400+ game catalog covers most major PS4 and PS5 third-party releases at $3 per month less than Premium.

Get PS Plus Extra
Xbox Game Pass Ultimate

Best for: Console and PC gamers who want the most complete subscription. Ultimate includes every Xbox and Bethesda first-party game on release day, EA Play, cloud gaming on Android and iOS, and online multiplayer in one subscription — though new Call of Duty titles no longer launch day one.

Try Game Pass Ultimate
ALSO COMPARE